4,231
Buildings
$1,650
Median 1BR Rent
Staten Island median: $4,338
325
Open Violations
2% of buildings affected
4.3 per building (borough median 7.8)
1956
Avg Year Built
Staten Island median: 1943
Building Map
Every pin is a building we track — color shows open HPD violations
Cost of Living
Based on active rental listings
| Type | Deal | Median | Luxury | Staten Island median |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Bedroom | $2,000 | $1,650/mo | $2,000 | $4,338(-62%) |
| 2 Bedrooms | $3,200 | $2,250/mo | $3,200 | $3,640(-38%) |
| 3 Bedrooms | — | $3,200/mo | — | $3,200 |
Deal = 25th percentile, Luxury = 75th percentile of active listings · (%) = this neighborhood vs the borough median
Building Quality
Violation distribution across 4,231 buildings
Typical neighborhood in the borough averages 7.8 open violations per building.
Property Managers
Largest management companies in this neighborhood
CASTLE GARDENS L L C
HILLCREST GARDEN LLC
CHURCH OF ST CLARE
UNAVAILABLE OWNER
R CUTTING
Buildings in Eltingville
4,231 tracked — every card links to a full report card
Showing 12 of 4,231
467 Armstrong Avenue
455 Armstrong Avenue
12 Hillcrest Avenue
14 Hillcrest Avenue
16 Hillcrest Avenue
18 Hillcrest Avenue
20 Hillcrest Avenue
22 Hillcrest Avenue
24 Hillcrest Avenue
26 Hillcrest Avenue
28 Hillcrest Avenue
4163b Amboy Road
Transit
1 subway station nearby
311 Complaints
Past 12 months across all buildings here
222
Among buildings with any noise complaints, the median logged 1 in the past year — a useful baseline when you compare individual buildings.
Bordering Neighborhoods
Adjacent on the map — worth checking in the same search
Get Spotted NYC
See violation data and building quality directly on StreetEasy, Zillow, and Apartments.com listings.
Install Extension