Eltingville

Staten Island · 4,231 buildings tracked

4,231

Buildings

$2,000

Median 1BR Rent

326

Open Violations

2% of buildings affected

1956

Avg Year Built

Cost of Living

Based on active rental listings

TypeDealMedianLuxury
1 Bedroom$2,000$2,000/mo$2,000
2 Bedrooms$3,200$3,200/mo$3,200
3 Bedrooms$3,500/mo

Deal = 25th percentile, Luxury = 75th percentile of active listings

Building Quality

Violation distribution across 4,231 buildings

Clean (0 violations)95%
Minor (1–5)1%
Moderate (6–10)1%
Severe (10+)0%
33 Class C (immediately hazardous) violations
16 pest-related violations
4 lead paint violations

Property Managers

Largest management companies in this neighborhood

1

CASTLE GARDENS L L C

12 buildings0 avg violations
2

HILLCREST GARDEN LLC

9 buildings3.8 avg violations
3

CHURCH OF ST CLARE

8 buildings0 avg violations
4

UNAVAILABLE OWNER

7 buildings0 avg violations
5

R CUTTING

6 buildings0 avg violations

Buildings in Eltingville

0 total

Transit

1 subway station nearby

IslandStaten
Eltingville
StatenIsland

311 Complaints

Past 12 months across all buildings here

253

Heat / Hot Water14
Noise211

Get Spotted NYC

See violation data and building scores directly on StreetEasy listings.

Install Extension