5 1/2 Caroll Street
Building overview
Data as of Jul 1, 2026
Based on open violations, 311 complaint patterns, and amenities.
Compared to typical rent for this neighborhood and bedroom count.
Highlights
What's great about this place
- Pre-war characterBuilt in 1930
- Quieter than average for the neighborhood0 noise complaints in past year (vs 1 median)
Things to Know
Real considerations before you sign
- Open critical violations7 Class C (immediately hazardous)
- Significant issues across building dataSee violation history below for details
About this building
A 1-story building located in Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island, containing 5 residential units. Built in 1930.
The neighborhood: City Island
Bronx · 2,025 buildings tracked
1 park · 0.1 acres · incl. Hawkins Park
Available Units
0 active
No past listings.
Past and off-market units will appear here when data is available.
Safety & Violations
Safety Record
Active Violations
Open HPD violations on record for this building.
Top issues
- General4
- Heat/Hot Water3
- Safety1
Severity Key
- Class C: Immediately Hazardous (Major)
- Class B: Hazardous (Moderate)
- Class A: Non-Hazardous (Minor)
- General
PROVIDE AN ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF GAS TO THE FIXTURES AT RANGE IN THE KITCHEN LOCATED AT APT 1, 1st STORY
Feb 28, 2013Class C - Heat/Hot Water
IN. CODE: ABATE THE NUISANCE CONSISTING OF EXTREMELY HOT WATER EXCEEDING 120 DEGREES CAUSING POTENTIAL SCALDING CONDITIONS AT FIXTURES IN THE BATHROOM AND IN THE KITCHEN LOCATED AT APT 1, 1st STORY
Feb 28, 2013Class C - Heat/Hot Water
IN. CODE: PROVIDE HOT WATER AT ALL HOT WATER FIXTURES IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 512, 1st STORY
Feb 20, 2013Class C - General
PROVIDE AN ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF GAS TO THE FIXTURES .. IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 512, 1st STORY
Feb 20, 2013Class C - Heat/Hot Water
IN. CODE: PROVIDE HOT WATER AT ALL HOT WATER FIXTURES IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT NA, 1st STORY
Jan 29, 2013Class C
Market Value Estimate
Statistical estimate based on publicly available listing data. Not an appraisal. See disclaimer.Market data as of Jul 1, 2026.
Comp Matrix
| Unit Type | This Bldg | Area Avg | Diff. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Studio | — | $4,000 | — |
| 1 Bed | — | $2,950 | — |
| 2 Bed | — | $3,400 | — |
| 3+ Bed | — | $3,700 | — |
Value Verdict
Insufficient listing or market data to compute a verdict for this building.
Rent vs. Buy Analysis
No listing data available to estimate rent vs. buy.
Management & Operations
Management & Performance
Owner/Operator
SUNSET COURTS INC
Cannot compute responsiveness yet. The building has 9 open violations but none have been resolved in our visibility window, so days-to-close has no data to average.
We haven't verified this building's policies yet. Pet, utility, and leasing details appear here once we've reviewed the management company's official site — we only show policies we can source, never assumptions.
Living here — quick answers
Every answer comes from public records for this specific building — we skip questions we can't answer with data.
- How well maintained is this building?
- There are 9 open HPD violations on record, including 7 Class C (the city's most serious category).
- How noisy is this building?
- Neighbors filed 0 noise complaints with 311 in the past year — none on record for this building.
- What does it cost to live here?
- We don't have current listings for this building. Typical asking rent in City Island is about $2,950/month for a one-bedroom.